19 Holiday Pie Recipes You Can Definitely Ace (2024)

Before you pick out that fabulous holiday dress and some fabulous accessories to go with it, you’ve got to figure out what you are going to make for dessert. You are in luck! We’ve got you covered with 19 pies and counting for your holiday dessert table.

1. Cranberry Pie with Rosemary Buttermilk Crust: We think the combination of savory rosemary and sweet cranberries is just genius. You can’t go wrong with this pie for the holidays! (via Une Gamine Dans La Cuisine)

2. Margarita Pie: If your family members enjoy a co*cktail or three around the holidays, this is the pie for you! It is delicious and fun all at the same time! (via Brit + Co.)

3. Easy Ice Cream Pie: We just love the holiday sprinkles on top of this pie! They totally bring us back! (via Alida’s Kitchen)

4. Peanut Butter Pie Shooters: Anything mini is just perfect for parties! These Peanut Butter Pie Shooters are the perfect bite-sized treats for your holiday dessert table. (via Pinch of Yum)

6. Chocolate Eggnog Swirl Pie: We happen to love eggnog over here at Brit + Co. If you are a fan, this pie will hit the sweet spot for you! (via Better Homes and Gardens)

7. Ultimate Pumpkin Pie: We don’t think the holidays are the holidays without some pumpkin pie. This Ultimate Pumpkin Pie recipe knocks our sweet tooth socks off, especially considering it has a layer of sugared pecans. (via Brit + Co.)

8. Pretzel Pie: We are absolutely giddy over how unique these Pretzel Pies are. And the best part is, you can fill them with your choice of filling! (via My Name Is Yeh)

9. Gingerbread Eggnog Pumpkin Pie: It doesn’t get anymore holiday than this! This has all of our holiday favorites wrapped up into one yummy pie! (via Thumb In Plum)

10. Banana Chocolate Pie: We love how beautiful the design is on top of this pie! It has sparked all kinds of ideas for us over here at Brit + Co., and we hope is does the same for you! (via Recipe For Happiness)

11. Butterscotch Pie: The fluffy white meringue on this pie takes our breath away. This is a show-stopping holiday pie! (via Adventures In Cooking)

12. Best Pecan Pie: Pecan Pie is not for the faint of heart. This sweet dessert will be a crowd-pleaser for the holidays. (via Rustic Peach)

13. Brown Butter Spice Cake with Sparkling Cranberries and Cream: Need we say more?! With “sparkling cranberries” this number is nothing short of perfection for the holidays! We get that this is a cake, but serving it in a round skillet dish constitutes a pie in our book. (via Willow Bird Baking)

14. Key Lime Pie with Chocolate-Almond Crust: Show your Christmas green with this Key Lime Pie recipe. On a side note, we can’t get over the sound of the chocolate-almond crust! (via Food & Wine)

15. Blueberry Hand Pies: This had us at “hand pies.” Anything that is a single portion and you can walk around with sounds like such easy-serving for the holidays. (via The Italian Dish)

16. Cranberry Meringue Pie Bites: Again our love for “mini” has reared its delightful head! And even better, these Cranberry Meringue Pie Bites look deliciously simple to make! (via Best Friends For Frosting)

17. Stuffed Apple Pie – The Healthiest Holiday Pie: This Stuffed Apple Pie is gluten-free and vegan. This is a great way to accommodate your holiday guests that have food constraints. (via The Food Click)

18. Salted Caramel Cheesecake Pie: Joy of Joy the Baker writes a delightfully witty food blog, but there is nothing funny about this pie. This recipe seriously takes the cake … or should we say pie?! (via Joy The Baker)

19. Chocolate Pie: This powdery chocolate pie almost looks too pretty to eat. It’s soft and wonderfully delicious for the holidays. (via Simone’s Kitchen)

We hope these pie recipes inspire you like they have inspired us! Now get out your mixing bowl and get to baking!

Kristi Murphy

Kristi Murphy is a lifestyle expert and the founder of KristiMurphy.com, an award-winning DIY blog where Kristi shares with her readers easy DIY ideas for a home,party, wardrobe, holiday, meal or wedding!

19 Holiday Pie Recipes You Can Definitely Ace (2024)

FAQs

What is the most popular pie holiday? ›

Thanksgiving and Christmas dominate the pie scene

Unsurprisingly, the most popular occasions for enjoying pie during the winter are the two major tentpoles of the holiday season, Thanksgiving (46%) and Christmas (41%). That makes for an 87% market share between the two of them.

What is inside a McDonald's holiday pie? ›

It's the greatest gift to yourself—creamy, smooth custard nestled in a flaky, buttery crust glazed with sugar and topped with rainbow sprinkles. There are 260 calories in McDonald's Holiday Pie. Order yours today from our full menu in the app using contactless Mobile Order & Pay* with Curbside pickup.

How long is the holiday pie at McDonald's? ›

A Holiday Tradition at McDonald's

Get it for a limited time at participating McDonald's locations nationwide from November 15th to December 30th.

What is the number 1 pie in America? ›

The clear winner for the United States as a whole was (not surprisingly) apple pie with more than 27% of sales going to the traditional flavor.

What three holiday pies are the most popular in order? ›

Google Trends data collected since November 2022 shows that the pies most searched for in the U.S. are pumpkin pie, apple pie, sweet potato pie, pecan pie and cranberry pie.

What dessert is McDonald's bringing back? ›

McDonald's first introduced the Strawberry & Crème Pie in 2012 and it was available nationally until 2014. The fast food chain brought it back briefly in 2022 but only in the spring or winter and only at select locations, according to AllRecipes.com.

Did McDonald's discontinue holiday pies? ›

McDonald's Holiday Pie made its first appearance in 1999 as part of a "Toy Story 2" promotion and, although it initially disappeared after the promotion, it made a comeback a little over 10 years later. Since then, it has become a seasonal favorite, and it's currently back for another stint on the menu.

What flavor pies are coming to McDonald's in 2024? ›

This year, McDonald's is bringing back one beloved, fruit-flavored pie that we can't wait to get our hands on. No, we're not talking about the cherry pie (rest in peace). We're talking about the Strawberry & Créme Pie.

What is the new pie at McDonald's? ›

In a move set to captivate taste buds across the country, McDonald's UK & Ireland have unveiled two new pink-themed hot and cold desserts this February - Raspberry and White Chocolate Pie and KitKat® Ruby Chocolate McFlurry® plus the Nestlé classic - KitKat® Milk Chocolate McFlurry®.

What is McDonald's new Holiday Pie? ›

McDonald's is ready for cozy season! This month, the brand announced that the fan-favorite holiday pie is back on the menu to make all your winter festivities even sweeter. The fun dessert is made of creamy custard wrapped in a flaky, buttery crust. The glaze is drizzled with sugar and features rainbow sprinkles.

Why does McDonald's apple pie taste so good? ›

Many pie fillings are made with a processed thickening agent that keeps the filling jelly-like and in place. But McDonald's uses a dehydrated apple powder. The powder not only thickens the filling, but it also adds that extra apple taste that you love.

What year did McDonald's stop frying their pies? ›

There are a lot of things that McDonald's does wrong, but deep-frying isn't one of them. Then, in 1992, the unthinkable happened: Ronald replaced his beloved fried apple pies with the vastly inferior, modern baked version.

Can you freeze holiday pies? ›

A well-wrapped pie, she says, will keep up to two months in the freezer. “It's best to freeze whole baked pies” after they've cooled, she says. “Wrap them tightly in plastic wrap and a layer of foil and freeze until firm. Thaw overnight in the fridge.

What states have McDonald's holiday pies? ›

Since being released, fans have seen it popping up all across the U.S. If you live in New York, New England, Illinois, Ohio, California, Texas, or Oregon, you may be able to find the Holiday Pie at your local McDonald's.

What is the most popular pie? ›

Apple pie is arguably one of the most popular pie flavors. A symbol of America, the apple pie was actually invented by the British.

What is the most popular holiday treat? ›

The winner: cheesecake, coming out on top in 28 states.

Some of the other favorites that came out on top were eggnog and cinnamon rolls. Hot chocolate also seems to be in most states' Top 5 favorites.

Is pumpkin or apple pie more popular for Thanksgiving? ›

While pumpkin pie often comes to mind when thinking of Thanksgiving treats, it was easily outpaced by apple pie across the U.S., taking the top spot in 34 states, with pumpkin pie the apparent favorite in just 14 states. The two outliers?

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5843

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Birthday: 1996-05-10

Address: Apt. 425 4346 Santiago Islands, Shariside, AK 38830-1874

Phone: +96313309894162

Job: Legacy Sales Designer

Hobby: Baseball, Wood carving, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Lacemaking, Parkour, Drawing

Introduction: My name is Dean Jakubowski Ret, I am a enthusiastic, friendly, homely, handsome, zealous, brainy, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.